Stay updated with free updates
just sign up film myFT Digest – delivered straight to your inbox.
Here is far from an exhaustive list of complaints. HamnettRetrieved from UK and US press. Paul Mescal plays William Shakespeare with the power of an “eunuch hosteler”. We should be crying for real-life Iranians killed instead of the long-gone playwright’s “imaginary boy.” The film’s closing music is “Volvo ad-friendly”. “What’s Hamnett… without a little ham?” Turning now to my WhatsApp account, friends of reliable judgment consider the film “terrible” or – worse – “midwit”.
This same film would, in the coming weeks, win awards by Bushell. Its five-star reviews could fill one of those posters on the Tube platform. Some come from critics whose views are considered similar ex cathedra.
Has another movie this decade polarized so many smart people? oppenheimer It had its flaws – Harry Truman was portrayed as an idiot with a Texan accent – ​​but no one lost their temper over it. Hamnett The power to be otherwise calm and well-adjusted is like Meghan Markle.
Perhaps this is the “vibe shift” at work: an ongoing reaction against the culture that trained us in sensitivity, treating suffering as an accomplishment, etc. HamnettAs envisioned in Walker’s time, 2026 could be very wet.
Well, I’m mostly in favor of the vibe change. I also subscribe to the old Jungian line that sentimentality is a mask for cruelty. After about an hour everything was ready to exit the cinema. instead, Hamnett This is the only movie I’ve gone to see twice since the pandemic. Of course, being above such things, I did not “cry”, but it is possible that two to three milliliters of salt-flavored leakage may have escaped from the general vicinity of my left eye socket.
The detractors have got it wrong. For many reasons, Hamnett Has the potential to advance our era.
One is its tact. You can feel the crunch of damp soil underfoot, the weight of a tankard in hand. The clever ones among them got Vermeer a job as an interior set designer. Of course, the risk of putting such a beautiful setting on screen is that it glamorizes the historical period. Hamnett Avoids that trap. The film brings out the cruelty of the world before the Newtonian era in which people held immaterial forces like fate and spirits responsible for their misfortunes. (Looking at the scenes of the plague, I had never before felt so angry about the anti-science cynicism of our time.) Even a slight softening of the mescal might be well judged. From everything we know about Shakespeare, it seems that he was a strange thing: an innate genius.
I think watching the movie as a non-parent helps. For those who have children, HamnettThe straightforward depiction of his extreme fear must seem cheap. Whereas I can deviate a bit from the central story and lose myself in other relationships, such as Shakespeare’s with his mean father, whom he silences with a threat, and above all with his wife. Without revealing the age of the couple, Hamnett It shows the impact that an older woman can have on a younger man’s life, even beyond sexual initiation.
If anything bothers, it’s Jessie Buckley as Mescal and his wife (the movie should really be called that). Agnes) Today’s hipsters resemble every attractive couple in north-east London. You keep expecting them to put down a deposit on a two-bed in De Beauvoir Square.
anyway, whatever Hamnett Yes, this is not a melodrama. Most of the lead parts are muted – especially Emily Watson as Shakespeare’s stern old mother – which gives Buckley license to work as the bereaved parent. Still, her cry of sorrow is loud. People complain about it as if she keeps fighting for hours. If there is a line that separates emotions from exploitation, Hamnett Remains onside, even though the final scene requires a VAR check.
So many people strongly think otherwise, it amazes me. This may say something about the changing climate of our times, the general exhaustion with constant emotional nakedness and suffering as a kind of trophy. I welcome that change in the air but there is a sense that it is starting to mess with people’s judgment, creating a kind of competitive frenzy. HamnettThe opposite of the present mood, is likely to be eternal.
Be the first to know about our latest stories – Follow FT Weekend Instagram, blue sky And xAnd Sign up To receive the FT Weekend newsletter every Saturday morning
